Skip to main content

Is more science better than less science?

  This heading was the beginning of an article written by Dr Vinad Prasad .

   Yes, he is a rebel but nevertheless he is also a specialist cardiologist so is well trained in science. The question intrigued me as I have written many times about the illusionary nature of conventional science. Mark twain said…’its not what we know that gets us into trouble, it’s what we think we know and don’t that is the problem.

The truth is that what we know is just a small part of the whole perhaps only 4% I read somewhere and based on this 4% we make major calculations, statistics and programs to treat ill health. The stats are a way of manipulating data to make it seem that the results could be applied to the whole population even though a very small part of the population took part in the trial. Imagine that. We are dealing with astonishing complexity and individual variations throughout the population of human beings and it seems okay to take a very small section of the population and based on this small group then have programs of management that is meant to cover the whole population. Think about it. Every individual has a unique profile of biochemical variations. It may be within the so called healthy normal profile, nevertheless it is unique to that person and suggests that there are different end points or balancing processes that healthy functions are maintaining.  It is for this reason that the same drug has different effects and side effects in everyone.  Increasing the size of the group tested increases the variation. The stats blend out the variations and why the conclusions of the study don’t really help when dealing with the individual.

A clever patient will ask…. Tell me doctor I hear the stats but how does it help me? Where do I fit in? Are you not just guessing my profile, my bodies responses? The truth is that I cannot assure the person that what I am suggesting is the best or even the right response. The science is useful for developing protocols and for governments and other agencies to formulate general approaches but for the doctor in practice the science is less helpful than most people would assume.

So here is the question again, all we need to do is more science so that our predictions can be better and our programs to treat ill health will correspondently improve.

It has not worked this way. We are advised to do a range of preventive measures such as colonoscopy, breast scans, prostate specific antigens (PSA), chest X-rays ect in order to diagnose early disease while curative treatment is still possible. The trouble was that the more testing doctors did the more complication as the result of testing appeared so that the pick-up rate of ill health was negated by the side effect profile of the testing itself. Colonoscopy for example can lead to perforations and biopsies of polyps may give false positives. Sending the same  x-ray to different radiologists gave different diagnosis.  Mammograms have similar problems from the damaging radiation to variations in the reading of the results and the serious anxiety produced by false positives.

As Dr Prasad says in his article, it is an assumption that science is always credible. There is enormous bias, pressure from pharmaceutical companies to get specific outcomes, conformity pressure from colleagues, funding pressure and just prestige and pressure to make breakthroughs and to top it all medical science focuses on a very small part of the whole which is physiology and anatomy. What is left out i.e. energy and information is entirely disregarded despite the fact that the controls running the living system must be in the latter which moves a great deal faster than biochemistry.

A reductionist, biochemical-only approach can lead to overdiagnosis, over treatment, and sometimes even disempowerment of the patient. On the other hand, more ‘science’ in the traditional sense often means more trials, more technology, more guidelines- but not necessarily more healing. Despite all the money invested in treating ill health, the American population in not anywhere close to the top of the list of healthy nations.

So, will more science solve the problem of ill health or only add to the complexity. Perhaps the better question is what kind of science. Conventional medicine as I have pointed out many times has been bought out by drug companies. There was a time just before the collapse of the Russian empire when medical research included biophysicist, engineers and biochemists. When I visited Russia during that time, medical schools and the hospitals were using a range of energy tools in the management of ill health. Every hospital had low energy lasers and energy devices to measure the energy fields of the body as a diagnostic tool and treatment.

Will adding energy measurement increase the effectiveness of diagnosis and treatment. What about psychics who can see the energy field (aura) for example would they help to get better outcomes, better diagnosis. That’s such an interesting question. My experience is that no matter how accurate your psychic diagnosis and ability is, the information is still being filtered by your particular filters and biases. The crack in the wall is not the real problem. The problem is much deeper, more complex and generally not easy to place a finger on it. It is diffuse, spread out through the building and even the ground on which the house is built.

So what kind of science is needed to go deeper, to be more comprehensive and effective for a human being functioning on multidimensional levels(matter-energy-informational-quantum) and an astonishing depth all the way to spirit, soul and consciousness and where both the objective and subjective aspects are real.

The conventional medical model is totally unfit to examine this whole complex living system in constant motion where even meaning and purpose influences the dynamics of flow. I have a particular fascination with Traditional Chinese Medicine which is over 2 thousand years old and has thousands of text books describing the way it works and how to use the acupuncture points to stimulate healing. Clearly this is a science too and what I call the ‘science of experience’. This is the science we all use daily and this experience is what is slowly refined as we meet life from moment to moment. The conventional science of Newton has disempowered us as we are told that the subjective is not real and only the objective is real. It confuses people who believe that their experience is as real as the objective reality that science uses.

This is why I define medicine as an art which uses science to measure what can be measured but most things about human beings cannot be measured and why good doctors are artists. Art is magical, expressive, a dance between two individuals that still needs techniques and knowing and even measurement but art nevertheless. Human beings are not ‘cases’ or ‘bodies’ but stories, souls, spirits in motion. You cannot treat a person like a machine and expect healing- you have to enter into relationship with them.

“In fact, science is not a collection of truths. It is a continuing exploration of mysteries” (Freedman Dyson). “

“The value of science, of all its many values, the greatest must be the freedom to doubt” (Richard Feynman).

We do not see things as they are, we see them as we are. (Anais Nin 1961)

Leave a Reply