Is good science the only way to establish truth about disease
Here is the problem. Are human beings – and all living things for that matter – just complex machine-like ‘things’ which can be taken apart, weighed and measured, evaluated by doing good science (such as dividing a number into two groups, treating the one group with a drug and not the other) and then assessing outcomes. It seems like a good idea, that is if human beings are just ‘things’ and function like machines.
If humans are not machines, and each unique in their own way all the way through, then we may be using the wrong science to assess them, and this is why many scientists are saying the following: ‘Only a handful of truly important drugs have been brought to market in recent years while the majority of drugs are drugs of dubious benefit.’ Marcia Angell 2004,past editor of New Eng J Med.
Epidemiologist John Ioannidis published an article in 2005 in a prestigious medical journal: ‘Why Most Published Research Findings Are False.’ And Richard Horton past editor of the Lancet wrote about contemporary medical science: ‘Afflicted by studies with small sample sizes, tiny effects, invalid exploratory analysis and flagrant conflict of interest, together with an obsession for pursuing fashionable trends of dubious importance, science has taken a turn towards darkness.’
Having done some research in the very early days, I know how easy it is to move results in the direction you want. Cases that don’t fit in and make the graph look untidy are often just left out of the final analysis. Good reasons are often found for this. The length of the trial will be contained as more side effects or problems begin to arise. Statistics can be easily adjusted to make the results seem much better than they really are, ofr example by using relative rather than absolute numbers.
The ‘old’ science often called ‘Newtonian science’ is the science of machines, and is really not tenable for living systems and should not be the gold standard for investigating living systems. The ‘new’ quantum science is much more appropriate to investigate human beings and life. It recognizes the nature of complexity in living systems, its flowing nature, its creative edge and ability to shift instantaneously throughout the system. Above all it has brought back consciousness and the subjective, and the recognition that there is always an elephant in the room. That elephant is all the unknown factors that are hidden in every moment, and there is a massive number of unknowns that science just ignores.
Unfortunately, conventional medicine is stuck in a paradigm that is now really controlled by companies that hold the purse strings. We saw in Covid how tight these purse strings were held to contain the narrative. As medical philosopher Jacob Stegenga says in his book Medical Nihilism: ‘We should have little confidence in the effectiveness of medical interventions.’ The point he makes throughout the book is how ‘malleable’ the methods are to test medical interventions. They are malleable I believe because human beings are malleable, unique in themselves, with a range of subjective phenomena that influence physiology, but of themselves cannot be measured. By removing all subjective phenomena such as love, anger, compassion, thought, consciousness, spirit, imagination from the field of examination the scientist has diminished the range of measuring activity to simple criteria which have little to do with the experience of being human, or for that matter which can lead to disease.
Medical science today has little to do with the living human being and more to do with the anatomy and physiology of a dead body. Keep in mind that the living being is a matter-energy-information-quantum being, and a body-emotions-mind-spirit-consciousness being. Check any textbook of physiology or biochemistry and see if you can find any reference to the human being as a whole. The information contained is an idealized version of a structural machine-like operating mechanism. Does it really work like that described?
Check out the results of modern medicine. Chronic disease remains chronic disease. Symptomatic improvement may happen for a period of time. As Stegenga says: ‘…the methods of medical research are malleable, and such malleability contributes to exaggerated claims of effectiveness of medical interventions.’
What constantly surprises me is the confidence the public tends to have in their doctors, specialists and hospital practice, despite the fact that ‘doctor induced problems’ are the third most common cause of ill health and death.
Medicine is an art that uses science to measure what can be measured, but most things about human beings cannot be measured, and this is why medicine can never be a pure science.
When human beings are approached as a complex flowing system and not as a broken machine, then the management of ill health is not simply fixing a broken part but about understanding and working with the larger, more complex whole. We are always having to deal with variables that cannot be controlled or even predicted, and a body, mind and spirit which interact in ways that science can observe but not always explain. Risk vs benefits are all about probability, and point to the uncertainty with which doctors have to practice, and why medicine will always remain an art.