The very strange placebo effect
I have written a great deal about placebo’s and even wrote a review article on the subject published in the SA Family Practice journal in 1992. The placebo however remains an enigma.
An advisory committee for the Food and Drug Administration in the USA recently concluded that a popular oral decongestant sold over the counter was no better than the placebo. The news was shocking apparently to both public but also medical doctors who had prescribed the product for years and believed that it did work. In the view of the commmittee the product may not work nevertheless it does seem to have benefit. That benefit is what is called a placebo effect and the question then is whether the practice of using a medicine now knowing that any good it does is ‘just’ a placebo is ethical. That is kind of a strange question for me because the placebo response is not just the physical pill itself but also the doctors attitude, the waiting room and even staff attitude so that if giving a placebo is unethical then what about just being nice to a patient when one is not really feeling great oneself …is that also unethical.
In a still earlier paper I wrote about the placebo effect, that ranged from 8-81%. No drug can beat 81% and why pharmaceutical companies don’t like having to compare their drug to a plain old sugar-coated tablet which still can compete with their drug making it look not as effective as the advertising around this product has suggested.
Even telling a person that they are only getting a placebo tablet does not seem to diminish the placebo effect. Very strange but true and points to the fact that this effect has little to do with the thinking mind but some deeper consciousness that responds to the act of giving rather than the contents of the medication.
While many respected professional specialists like to think that the placebo is ‘soft’ medicine and cannot really influence hard pathology like cancer or other serious diseases, I am not at all sure that this is true. I have written a paper on the power of prayer and there is some good science to show that this helps peoples outcomes in hospital. There is also good evidence that cancers can go into spontaneous remissions as can other chronic diseases so why would anyone not believe that ‘consciousness’ or whatever that intelligence is that initiates healing cannot effect ‘matter’ like cancer.
There is also the Nocebo effect which is the opposite of the placebo effect in which words of the doctor can cause negative responses in the patient. This really is not different to the ‘black magic’, witchcraft, sorcery and the invocation of evil spirits for evil purposes. The latter are known to cause serious maladies in people and even death.
The big question that remains unanswered is how much of the different drug responses are mainly due to the placebo effect. The fact is that there is a placebo effect obviously for the placebo but how much of a so-called drug effect is also due to a placebo response. People are responding not via their thinking mind but via some much deeper unconscious mechanism. This is pointing to the placebo as functioning outside conventional scientific parameters and why medical science is having difficulty in understanding how it works. I believe that the placebo is operating at the quantum level with deep consciousness involved. Conventional medicine has little understanding of consciousness and this is why the placebo is an enigma.
Dr Wayne Jonas, professor of medicine at GeorgeTown university has written a book called ‘How Healing works”. In the final pages of the book he says the following:
•“When examined through rigorous science, using randomisation, double blinding and placebo controls with adequate numbers of patients, most treatments for the most common chronic conditions either do not work or work only 20 to 30% of the time.
•Most of the drugs prescribed for pain, mental health, ulcers, hypertension, diabetes, Parkinson’s disease, and many other conditions show little benefit, with improvement in a minority of those studied.
•Even surgery , the king of modern medicine, works very seldom for chronic disease when studied in a rigorous manner.
•The majority of improvement for many treatments occurs with the fake or placebo treatment, whether the placebo is mimicking a drug, herb, needle, or knife.
Those are astonishing statements from a professor of medicine pointing to the massive influence of the placebo and how it effects outcomes in treatment. Keep constantly in mind that the placebo is not just about handing the patient a non-active pill mimicking the drug but also includes a range of environment factors . Then there is also the patient’s own inner history and psychological factors which govern the interior environment and peoples responses .
So be careful how you think about the placebo because it reaches into everyday living as well. Hugging a person, saying nice words to someone, encouraging a child or adult, a hand on the shoulder, listening to music, running etc are all the ways one can influence positive outcomes. The placebo is a word than can be very narrowly defined as a non-active pill or widely defined to include all the other factors mentioned above. Argument arise when one person insists on a narrow definition and the other person sees a much bigger picture.
I am not suggesting that one should just use dummy pills to treat illness because anything works. That in my mind is unethical and not professional but to listen to ones heart, use remedies and approaches that resonate fully with one’s own inner guidance. One needs to be coherent with oneself all the way through from mind to heart to soul to consciousness and then respond to each situation. That is ethical and then the possibility of obtaining a healing is most likely. The placebo effect is working through all these modalities and approaches and that is why healing is an art and even magical.